American travel budgets are down 23 percent, but people are shrinking the trip, not skipping it. A CheapCaribbean survey found 58 percent planning to spend less. The line that broke ranks is airfare, up 26.5 percent year on year against 3.4 for eating out, which is why 35 percent are driving instead of flying.

The cuts land in a clear order:

  • Dining out first (42 percent), then shopping and souvenirs (40).
  • Trip length next (33), but a shorter trip is still the trip.
  • Only then the upgrades, the premium seat and nicer room (32).

The top of the market, though, spends more: Deloitte calls it a bifurcation of premium and luxury. And 72 percent will move their dates, the lever that pays best, because a Tuesday costs less than a Saturday for an identical sight. The best part of a trip, 66 percent say, costs nothing.